Skip to main content

About Controversial Doctrines

My dictionary taught me that controversy is anything that produces disagreements, debates, opposition, division, and even quarreling. Controversial doctrines, therefore, are those kinds of Bible teachings that some believers don’t subscribe to, if not disagree to the point of separation. There is a difference between heretical teachings and controversial ones. A heretical teaching is that which is outright unbiblical and anti-Gospel and would be condemned by both sides of the Christian debate. Controversial doctrines, however, though often labeled as such, are not heretical. But are simply born out of a different viewpoint or understanding of certain Bible verses, in light of the whole Biblical truth. All this does not mean that God is the author of confusion. He is indeed infallible in His declared truth, yet our understanding is not. We are finite creatures that are still on the long road towards wisdom and maturity.

Most of the divisions and denominations found in the Christian Church are born out of these controversial subjects. Some believers feel like they cannot, in good conscience, have fellowship with those who don’t hold onto the same viewpoints on these particular subjects. These issues are so serious that churches are careful about who and what is taught from their pulpits, in fact, in some places you cannot discuss these topics without being run out as a deceiver according to their standard.  What are those controversial topics that are so sensitive to cause such unfortunate contentions?

1.) Tithe – I believe there is no issue that has caused and still continues to cause fighting among Pastors and believers than the issue of tithe. It used to be that everyone agreed that it was okay for believers to put aside a 10% of their monthly earnings and gave it to the church. Not anymore! Because of the abuses of the false prophets, a new sect of believers has emerged, claiming to have gone to the Bible and discovered that tithe was not a mandate for the New Testament believers. It was then that a big fight ensued. Some believers left the pro-tithe churches and sought the free-will-giving preachers. At the same time, another group remained on the other side of the fence – also claiming to have restudied the Bible and understood that there was nothing wrong with tithe. The tithe battle is still raging on with no sign of it ever ending any time soon.

2.) Calvinism – Many of us had zero idea of what Calvinism was. As far as we knew, we were only normal Bible believers like everybody else. What a surprise it was when were labeled as false because we were teaching “Calvinism.” For those who still don’t know. A Calvinist is the one who believes that God predestined or has already chosen those whom He wanted to save, before the world began. Hence salvation is not dependent on your decision of “choosing Jesus”, but on Jesus choosing you, while allowing the rest to go to hell. Indeed there is more to Calvinism than the doctrine of election, however, this is the most controversial one. Some folks just cannot handle the idea of a loving, good God electing some people to salvation while leaving others outside the plan of redemption. To them, “whosoever” believes in Jesus will be saved. Regardless of the side of the fence you find yourself in, Calvinism remains one of the fiercely debated doctrines of this Christian era.

3.) Women Preachers – Traditionally, congregates had no problem with the church being led strictly by men, I mean the Pastoral role. However, we are seeing a huge shift from that system to a more flexible church life where women can even be ordained into Pastorate – all thanks to the rise of the women rights movement. This “new trend” however, has not remained without opposition from fellow believers who are of the opinion that Scripture is clear that ladies should not exercise authority over men.  Whatever your position is on this issue, the reality is that it remains a point of massive controversy and division.

4.) King James Version – I have been to the bookstore a few times, and I don’t remember ever having any trouble with purchasing the ESV, NLT, or even NIV. Nevertheless, I know and fully understand that some believers are of the belief that you don’t have a Bible unless you own that old King James Bible Authorized Version.  In fact, it only takes a few YouTube videos from either camp to realize how severe if not wearisome this debate is and the subsequent name-calling that it has caused among the Christian community.

5.) False Teachers – I love preaching, at least everything in the Bible but the topic of false teachers.  Every time, before and after I preach about this I feel like quitting the ministry altogether because I am human enough to be affected by the criticism I often receive from fellow believers who strongly believe that we must not touch the “anointed”. That we must all understand that there is no perfect man of God, hence we must not judge but allow God to decide who is false and who is not. Therefore, the issue of false prophets is indeed a controversial one. 

Once again, I have run out of paper, otherwise, I could have gone into more controversial topics like speaking in tongues, rapture, baptism, cessationism and once saved always saved. However, allow me to end with these key points. That is, disagreements among us will always be there as long we have different traditions and experiences, however, never miss the fact that we are brothers in Christ, regardless of these divisive matters.  Hence it is definitely unchristian to develop a bitter spirit towards those whom Christ has justified just because they don’t subscribe to your interpretation. Even worse, it is immature to always find yourself calling names to every believer who disagrees with you – as if you are the one with perfect theology. By the way, our level of growth is different, hence some of us are still learning these great truths of the Christian faith. Should we then be blamed if we have not come to such levels of knowledge?  Therefore, in these doctrinal squabbles, we must be considerate of certain baby believers who are still growing in their walk with the good Lord, lest we find ourselves confusing them all the more if not entirely ruining their pure hearts. Finally, beware, lest we find ourselves using so much time and energy preoccupied with side debates, to the neglect of the central assignment – the great Gospel message that sinners still wait to hear. “The main thing is to keep the main thing the main thing.” I think I have made my case, hence I will leave it here.

Sinothi Ncube

Related Content...

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Tithe; The Hidden Truth That You Will Never Be Told

Evangel Africa does not glory in controversies but that everyone may come to the truth of the Gospel as written in Scripture, hence we do encourage everyone to test all our teachings in light of what the Bible says. On that note, without fear or favour, we are going to correctly explain the real truth about tithe that you were never told; its origin and its application to the New Testament believers . This might be the most important thing you will ever read. First, understand this The foundation of all this must begin with your understanding about Covenants. There are two main covenants in the Bible, the Old Covenant and the New Covenant . The Old Covenant was a binding agreement between God and specifically the people of Israel, through strict obedience of the Law in return for God’s blessings (Duet 28:1-14) – while the New Covenant is a binding agreement between God and all people through the work of Jesus on the Cross in return to doing nothing but just faith in Christ (Heb 8:6-13)

Locating the Right Lady for Marriage

I was listening to a local radio station and the topic was about the modern generation of men who are no longer interested in being married. In some sense, I can resonate with that because I remember the frustration I had when I was ready for marriage; there was no one among all the church ladies who was woman enough to deserve my hand of marriage. Why is this so, why does it seem like it is becoming harder for church boys to find suitable partners? Now as a disclaimer, this is a Believers-only discussion, we have no business with what worldly people do in the lust of their flesh. Nonetheless, suppose you were hunting for that dream girl, what characters would you look for? Let’s dig in… Salvation I am sorry, but this is non-negotiable. You can’t and you will not build any sustainable Christian home with an unbeliever. A goat will always be a goat and will by no means cooperate with sheep. As I hinted a few articles ago that the greatest challenge in the church today is that a great ma

Is the Church the New & True Israel?

I know that we have strong opinions about this issue. And also our emotions are quite attached to this conversation; all shaped by our experiences, political affiliations and the like – understandably so. However, my duty is to deal with this question: what does the Bible say? Whenever we start with that question, guaranteed, we are shielded from our biases towards the actual truth of the matter. Believe it or not, this is one of the most important things to learn and to have a clear understanding of. It will affect how you read the Bible. Even more, a clear understanding of this issue will affect your attitude toward Jewish people who are in Israel today. Who is Israel by the way? Believe it or not, there are some who disagree on this question, hence I will just let Paul tell us who an Israelite is when he says, … “For I myself am an Israelite, a descendant of Abraham, a member of the tribe of Benjamin… ”( Rom 11:1 ). Therefore, only the physical, direct descendants of Abraham, Isaac

My Personal Issue With the SDA Church

Indeed I used the word “personal” as the headline of my script, yet the truth is, I have no personal problem with any faith, or church whatsoever. My issue is and will always be a doctrinal one . That is, I begin by looking at Scripture and the truth therein, then use that to judge my own life, and also anything else, including churches and other religions at large. As you might expect, the views expressed in this article are not coming from hear-say, but I have done my homework and consulted the official sources from our brothers in the Seventh Day Adventist Church. These are the concerning issues I have found out. Ellen G White If perhaps you are new to this name, Ellen White is not only the founder of the Seventh- Day movement, but her teachings are also the basis of the entire SDA Church doctrine. Her writings are what the SDA members call “the spirit of prophecy”. It is concerning enough that what she wrote is regarded by the Adventist Church as being “divinely inspired” (on the s